In the modern-day economy, influencers play a pivotal role in driving consumerism, and guiding the choices and behaviors of their followers. While influencer marketing sounds like a foolproof marketing strategy, finding the right influencers to promote your brand on social media could be a hassle. As per a research, 48% of brands are still struggling to find the right creators for them.

What is Influencer Discovery?

Influencer discovery is the process of finding and identifying influencers who align with your brand’s values, target audience, and marketing goals. It involves using various tools and strategies to search, filter, and vet relevant influencers for potential influencer collaborations and partnerships.

Challenges of Influencer Discovery for Brands and Agencies

Finding the perfect influencer is more than just choosing someone with a high follower count. It requires a strategic approach to ensure that the audience, engagement rates, and brand alignment of the influencer you’re picking, match your brand's goals. It’s like finding a needle in a haystack, sometimes it could be even more challenging.

If you’re not aware of how one tone-deaf marketing misstep by Morphe cost them everything, you can read all about it here. But yeah, this is how important finding the right influencers could be!

Here are some Reddit opinions on the downfall of Morphe, check out what people have to say:

To be 'Cancelled' is the worst nightmare of a brand marketer. It's like experiencing a social death that eventually leads to more and more decline and irrelevance.

Influencer discovery is a crucial step in an influencer marketing strategy, as it helps brands find the right influencers to promote their products or services. Effective influencer discovery can lead to successful collaborations, increased brand awareness, and improved marketing ROI.

Now, the questions arises - How to find an influencer that aligns with your brand values?

Here’s how:

1. Define Your Target Audience:

When defining your target audience, you should break it down into several factors: age, gender, location, interests, and behaviors. Tools like Google Analytics, Facebook Audience Insights, and social media listening platforms can help gather this information. Furthermore, understanding psychographics—like motivations, attitudes, and pain points—can refine this definition even more. The more you know about your audience, the better you can match them with an influencer who speaks their language and shares their values. This alignment increases the chances that your message will be well-received and acted upon.

2. Analyze Engagement, Not Just Follower Count:

Engagement metrics are critical because they represent how involved an influencer’s followers are with the content. For instance, an influencer with 500,000 followers and a 0.5% engagement rate (only 2,500 likes or comments per post) might not be as valuable as someone with 50,000 followers but a 5% engagement rate (2,500 likes or comments per post). Social media algorithms, especially on platforms like Instagram and TikTok, favor content with high engagement, meaning influencers with engaged audiences can lead to better reach and visibility. Use engagement analysis tools like Phyllo or Social Blade to measure these metrics before deciding.

3. Authenticity and Brand Alignment:

Influencers with a genuine connection to your brand or industry will create more natural and relatable content. For instance, if you’re a sustainable fashion brand, choosing an influencer who regularly promotes eco-conscious living will resonate more with their audience than someone who frequently promotes fast fashion. Additionally, examine the influencer’s content for consistency in messaging and tone. A mismatch in brand alignment can lead to disingenuous collaborations, which audiences quickly pick up on, reducing the overall effectiveness of the campaign.

4. Leverage Data and Analytics Tools:

Analytics platforms do more than just list influencers. They allow you to dive deep into audience demographics, influencer authenticity scores (detecting fake followers), and content performance metrics. Tools like Traackr and Upfluence even allow for influencer segmentation, helping you find niche influencers that cater to specific audience segments within your industry. Some tools can also predict future campaign performance based on historical data, enabling more data-driven decision-making. Make sure to leverage these tools to ensure that the influencers you’re considering align with both your short-term and long-term marketing goals.

5. Monitor Past Partnerships:

A strong indicator of an influencer’s potential success with your brand is their performance in past collaborations. 

Look at their sponsored posts: Do their followers engage positively with branded content, or is there a noticeable dip in interaction compared to their organic content? If an influencer has promoted competitors or brands with conflicting values, this may also negatively impact the success of your campaign. 

Reaching out to brands that have previously worked with the influencer for feedback can provide valuable insights into their professionalism and campaign results.

6. Prioritize Long-Term Relationships:

Building long-term relationships with influencers is one of the most effective ways to strengthen your brand’s presence in their community. It shows the audience that the influencer truly believes in the brand, which leads to more genuine recommendations. Influencers who repeatedly work with a brand over time can naturally integrate the product or service into their lifestyle, resulting in more organic and authentic content. Additionally, long-term partnerships often lead to better financial agreements, where both the influencer and the brand benefit from a continued collaboration.

7. Micro vs. Macro Influencers:

It’s worth noting that the rise of nano-influencers (influencers with fewer than 10,000 followers) can also be an effective strategy, especially for smaller, niche brands. These influencers typically have very intimate relationships with their followers, and their recommendations are often seen as more trustworthy. On the flip side, macro or even celebrity influencers are beneficial for larger campaigns focused on massive brand awareness or event promotions. Deciding between micro, macro, or even nano-influencers depends on your campaign objectives, budget, and the kind of audience connection you seek.

Now that we know what to look for, let’s jump quickly into how to look for a perfect influencer to promote your brand.

When looking for the right influencer for your brand, the process can be approached in two ways: manually or by using automated tools. Both methods have their own benefits and drawbacks depending on your goals, resources, and budget. Let’s explore the differences between manual and automated influencer discovery in terms of time, accuracy, and reach.

Manual Influencer Discovery

Manual influencer discovery involves researching and identifying influencers on platforms like Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, or Twitter without the use of specific tools designed for influencer search. Here’s how it compares:

1. Time:

Manual discovery can be incredibly time-consuming. It requires you to search through social media profiles, hashtags, or keywords that are relevant to your brand. You’ll need to analyze individual profiles, scroll through posts, check follower count, engagement, and verify their audience demographics by reading comments and tracking their interactions over time.

• Pros: You have complete control over the process and can dive deep into each influencer’s profile, ensuring they align with your brand.
• Cons: It’s a slow and labor-intensive process, especially if you’re targeting multiple influencers or running large campaigns.

2. Accuracy:

When done right, manual discovery can be highly accurate. By personally reviewing an influencer’s content, engagement, and followers, you can ensure they fit your brand’s tone, values, and goals. You can also evaluate the authenticity of their interactions and gauge whether their followers are genuine or bots.

• Pros: Greater accuracy when it comes to selecting influencers who align with your brand’s niche and values.
• Cons: It’s harder to accurately track engagement metrics, follower growth, and fake follower detection unless you have access to specific data or paid tools. Personal biases may also influence decision-making.

3. Reach:

The reach of manual influencer discovery is often limited by your resources and ability to research. Unless you have a dedicated team, you may miss out on valuable influencers who operate in different niches or smaller but impactful audiences.

• Pros: You can tailor your search to very specific influencers who match your brand’s vision.
• Cons: It’s hard to scale beyond a certain point, and discovering influencers in new or niche markets can be difficult.

Automated Influencer Discovery

Automated influencer discovery involves using software platforms like Phyllo, Traackr, Upfluence, or HypeAuditor to streamline the process of finding influencers. These influencer marketing tools use algorithms to analyze data points, including engagement rates, audience demographics, and follower authenticity.

1. Time:

Automated search tools drastically reduce the time required to find influencers. With a few clicks, you can filter influencers by follower count, engagement rate, niche, location, and more. These platforms often provide instant access to a wide database of influencers, saving hours or even days of manual searching.

• Pros: Fast and efficient, allowing you to discover and evaluate multiple influencers within minutes.
• Cons: You may miss the personal touch or subtle nuances that can only be seen by manually reviewing an influencer's content.

2. Accuracy:

Automated tools use data analytics to measure engagement, audience demographics, and even flag suspicious activity like fake followers. These tools are typically accurate in providing key metrics like engagement rates and audience insights, which can give you a clearer picture of an influencer's impact.

• Pros: High accuracy when it comes to numbers and data-driven insights. Some tools offer detailed reports on past campaigns, influencer performance, and audience interests.
• Cons: While accurate in terms of data, these tools might overlook qualitative factors, such as the influencer’s content style, brand fit, or subtle indicators of authenticity that manual review can capture.

3. Reach:

Automated platforms have vast databases of influencers, from micro to macro, across different platforms and regions. This gives you access to a much broader pool of potential collaborators, especially in different industries or new markets.

• Pros: Wide reach and access to thousands of influencers that would be hard to find manually. These tools can help you discover influencers you may never have come across otherwise.
• Cons: You may feel overwhelmed by the sheer volume of influencers, and sorting through the data to find the best fit may require some additional effort.

Which Method Should You Choose?

• For Smaller Campaigns: If you’re running a smaller or highly niche campaign and have time on your hands, manual discovery allows for a personal touch and ensures that the influencers align well with your brand ethos.
• For Larger Campaigns: If your brand needs to find a large number of influencers or operates in a highly competitive market, automated tools offer speed, efficiency, and access to a broader range of influencers with valuable metrics. They also allow for better scalability and targeting.
• Blended Approach: You might also consider a hybrid approach. Start with an automated tool to identify potential influencers and filter down based on metrics. Then, manually vet the shortlisted influencers to ensure they are a perfect fit for your brand.

By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each method, you can choose the right approach for your specific influencer marketing needs, balancing efficiency with quality and brand alignment.

Best Practices for Effective Influencer Discovery

There are around 64 million influencers in the world, as per the data shared by trendHERO in 2023, and this number has only gone up since this data was collated. The influencers are here to stay and they’re molding the decisions of the masses, driving them to you or away from you. 

So, how would you find the ones who are destined just for you? Well, fret not.

If the world is your oyster, let this article be your oracle and guide you to the best practices for effective influencer discovery. Here’s how you can pinpoint the influencers that align with your brand:

1. Define Clear Objectives:

Before you start your influencer search, clearly outline what you aim to achieve with your campaign. Are you focused on raising brand awareness, driving traffic to your website, increasing conversions, or improving brand sentiment? Understanding your campaign goals will help you identify the right type of influencers (macro, micro, or nano) and the platforms that best align with your objectives.

• Best Practice: Match the type of influencer to the campaign goal. For example, macro-influencers for large-scale awareness campaigns and micro/nano-influencers for engagement-driven campaigns.

2. Understand Your Audience:

Effective influencer discovery starts with knowing who your target audience is. The influencers you choose must be able to resonate with that audience in terms of language, interests, and values. Use demographic and psychographic data to understand your audience’s online behaviors and preferences.

• Best Practice: Look for influencers who share a similar audience profile to your target demographic, including age, location, interests, and behaviors.

3. Focus on Engagement, Not Just Follower Count:

Influencer reach is important, but engagement is even more critical. An influencer with 10,000 followers and a 5% engagement rate can be more valuable than one with 100,000 followers but only a 1% engagement rate. High engagement indicates a loyal audience that is more likely to act on the influencer’s recommendations.

• Best Practice: Use engagement metrics such as likes, comments, shares, and follower interactions to evaluate the influencer’s connection with their audience.

4. Leverage Influencer Discovery Tools:

Manual discovery can be time-consuming and inefficient at scale. Utilize influencer discovery platforms like Phyllo, Upfluence, Traackr, or HypeAuditor to streamline your search. These tools allow you to filter influencers by follower count, engagement rates, demographics, location, and more.

• Best Practice: Choose a discovery tool that offers detailed insights, including engagement metrics, audience demographics, and authenticity scores, so you can make data-driven decisions.

5. Analyze Audience Demographics:

The success of an influencer campaign depends not just on the influencer, but on their audience. It’s important to ensure that the influencer’s followers match your target demographic. Use tools that offer insights into an influencer’s audience breakdown by age, gender, location, and interests to further identify influencers and ensure a good fit.

• Best Practice: Look beyond surface-level metrics and analyze an influencer’s audience to ensure it aligns with your brand’s target market.

6. Check for Fake Followers and Engagement Fraud:

The presence of fake followers and engagement fraud can significantly affect your campaign’s effectiveness. Some influencers may use bots or other unethical methods to artificially inflate their follower count or engagement numbers. Use tools that analyze the authenticity of an influencer’s audience.

• Best Practice: Use authenticity-checking tools like Social Blade or HypeAuditor to detect bots, fake followers, and suspicious activity in an influencer’s audience.

7. Look at Influencer’s Past Collaborations:

Review the influencer’s history of brand partnerships. This will give you insights into whether they’ve worked with similar brands and how their audience responded to those collaborations. It will also help you understand if they have oversaturated their audience with too many sponsored posts, which can lead to audience fatigue.

• Best Practice: Look for influencers with a balanced mix of organic and sponsored content. Evaluate the success of their previous campaigns by checking engagement rates and audience sentiment on sponsored posts.

8. Evaluate Content Quality:

It’s important to assess the type and quality of content that an influencer produces. High-quality visuals, storytelling, and the ability to create engaging and informative content are key factors that influence audience engagement. Make sure the influencer’s aesthetic and tone match your brand’s identity.

• Best Practice: Review the influencer’s content, including videos, images, captions, and stories, to ensure their style aligns with your brand and meets the expectations of your target audience.

9. Consider Platform-Specific Influencers:

Each social media platform has its own culture and type of content that resonates with users. Some influencers may perform better on specific platforms like Instagram (visual storytelling), TikTok (short, engaging videos), or YouTube (long-form content). Choose influencers who are strong on the platforms where your audience spends the most time.

• Best Practice: Match the influencer’s strengths with the platforms most relevant to your audience. For example, if your target audience prefers video content, YouTube or TikTok influencers may be more effective.

10. Measure Campaign Success and Adjust:

Once your campaign is live, track the success of the influencer's performance. Use key performance indicators (KPIs) such as engagement rate, reach, conversion rate, and ROI. Continuously analyze data to understand what worked and what didn’t, and use those insights to refine future influencer selections and strategies.

• Best Practice: Set up UTM codes, trackable links, and unique discount codes to measure the exact impact of influencer campaigns on your business objectives.

How Phyllo Simplifies Influencer Discovery for Brands

In today's digital landscape where influencer marketing has become an essential strategy for brands, the process of discovering the right influencers manually can be extremely time-consuming and resource-intensive. This is where Phyllo, with its Creator Discovery API, steps in to revolutionize the way brands identify and collaborate with influencers. Let's take a look at how Phyllo can make your life easier:

Access to a Vast Influencer Pool

Phyllo's Creator Discovery API provides access to over 400 million influencer profiles across various social media platforms, as of September 2024.

Instead of manually sifting through social media profiles, brands can instantly tap into a comprehensive database of content creators, helping them find influencers who resonate with their audience. Whether your brand is looking for niche micro-influencers or high-reach macro-influencers, Phyllo simplifies the discovery process by offering detailed, real-time insights into each creator's content, engagement metrics, and audience demographics.

Advanced Filtering and Sorting Options

With Phyllo, brands can save time by leveraging advanced filtering and sorting features that streamline influencer selection. Brands can apply filters based on audience size, engagement rates, content type, location, and much more. 

This precision search tool ensures that you only focus on influencers who meet your specific marketing objectives, helping you avoid the hassle of sifting through irrelevant profiles.

Vetting High-Quality Influencers

Not all influencers are created equal, and working with the wrong ones can harm your brand's reputation. Phyllo’s Creator Discovery API automates the vetting process by providing accurate data on influencer performance and authenticity. 

Brands can easily verify the credibility of influencers by analyzing real-time engagement rates, follower growth trends, and audience authenticity metrics. This ensures that your brand partners with top influencers, who are genuinely capable of driving meaningful engagement.

Other than this, with Brand Fit APIs, Phyllo also provides a tool called Brand Fit Score that helps brands and marketers evaluate how well a creator aligns with their brand’s values, goals, and audience. It leverages data from social media platforms and APIs to analyze creators’ content, audience demographics, engagement metrics, and brand mentions to generate a score that indicates the likelihood of a good partnership fit.

Seamless Integration and Customization

Phyllo’s API is designed to seamlessly integrate into your existing workflows and marketing tools. Whether you're managing multiple influencer campaigns or looking to automate the entire discovery process, the Creator Discovery API offers flexibility and scalability to meet your needs. 

Brands can customize their search criteria and access data in real-time, helping them stay ahead in the fast-paced world of influencer marketing.

Time and Resource Efficiency

One of the key benefits of using Phyllo is the amount of time and resources it saves. By automating influencer discovery, brands can focus more on strategy, content creation, and relationship-building with influencers, rather than spending hours on manual research. This not only increases efficiency but also allows marketing teams to scale their efforts and achieve better results in a shorter timeframe.

Phyllo’s Creator Discovery API simplifies influencer discovery for brands by providing access to a vast pool of influencers, offering powerful filtering and sorting options, automating vetting, and integrating seamlessly with your marketing tools. By utilizing Phyllo, brands can discover high-quality influencers faster, ensuring that their marketing campaigns are both efficient and impactful.

Building Your Influencer Database with Phyllo

But what if you’re not a brand marketer? What if you’re a developer or a product manager looking to build a platform that offers influencer discovery feature?

Well, then you’re at the right place! Not only does Phyllo enable brands to find the right fit of influencers, but it also empowers developers to integrate the same feature into their product with the help of the Creator Discovery API.

Phyllo’s Creator Discovery API coupled with their Profile Analytics API can help you create a strong database for your potential customers where they can deep dive into influencer data to find the right fit for their marketing needs. 

Since these APIs are almost plug and play APIs, the integration will be hassle-free and easy. In no time, your extensive creator data pool will be up and running, attracting customers from all sides of the world.

In the end

Influencer discovery is a complex but essential process for brands looking to build impactful marketing campaigns. Instead of focusing solely on follower count, brands need to strategically find influencers who align with their values and audience. This involves understanding audience demographics, analyzing engagement metrics, and ensuring authenticity in every partnership. 

To maximize marketing efforts, it is essential to partner with the right influencers since they’re the ones who are eventually driving the purchases of your potential customers.

By leveraging tools like Phyllo’s Creator Discovery API, brands can simplify the often time-consuming process of finding influencers. These tools offer advanced search filters, real-time engagement insights, and authenticity checks. The result is more efficient, data-driven decision-making that aligns with both short-term goals and long-term brand-building efforts.

For developers, Phyllo’s API offers seamless integration, enabling them to add influencer discovery features into platforms with ease. Whether used by brands or developers, this solution makes influencer marketing more accessible and scalable, helping brands identify the perfect influencers for their campaigns.

‍